Merrill Lynch Charged With Trading Controls Failures That Led to Mini-Flash Crashes
An SEC investigation found that Merrill Lynch caused market disruptions on at least 15 occasions from late 2012 to mid-2014 and violated the Market Access Rule because its internal controls in place to prevent erroneous trading orders were set at levels so high that it rendered them ineffective. For example, Merrill Lynch applied a limit of 5 million shares per order for one stock that only traded around 79,000 shares per day. Other trading strategies had limits set as high as 25 million shares, which Merrill Lynch reduced to 50,000 shares after the SEC’s investigation began.
According to the SEC’s order instituting a settled administrative proceeding, the erroneous orders that passed through Merrill Lynch’s internal controls caused certain stock prices to plummet and then suddenly recover within seconds. Among the mini-flash crashes were 99-percent drops in the stocks of Anadarko Petroleum Corporation on May 17, 2013, and Qualys Inc. on April 25, 2013. Another order led to a nearly 3-percent decline in Google’s stock in less than a second on April 22, 2013.
“Mini-flash crashes, such as those caused by Merrill Lynch, can undermine investor confidence in the markets,” said Andrew Ceresney, Director of the SEC Enforcement Division. “It is essential that broker-dealers with market access have reasonable controls to prevent erroneous orders that disrupt trading.”
Robert Cohen, Co-Chief of the SEC Enforcement Division’s Market Abuse Unit, added, “This is the highest-ever SEC penalty for violations of the Market Access Rule. Despite multiple red flags, Merrill Lynch failed to evaluate adequately whether its controls were reasonably designed and failed to fix the problems quickly.”
The SEC’s order finds that Merrill Lynch also violated the Market Access Rule’s requirement for annual CEO certifications in 2013 and 2014. Merrill Lynch consented to the SEC’s order without admitting or denying the findings. In addition to paying the \\$12.5 million penalty, Merrill Lynch agreed to be censured and must cease and desist from further violations of Section 15(c)(3) of the Securities Exchange Act and Rule 15c3-5.
The SEC’s investigation was conducted by Tara Kelly and Ainsley Kerr and supervised by Carolyn Welshhans, Yuri B. Zelinsky, Mr. Cohen, and Associate Director Antonia Chion. The SEC appreciates the assistance of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority.